Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Court strikes out suit to compel Buhari to implement anti-open grazing law

The judge said that it was the responsibility of the people of Benue and law enforcement agencies to implement the anti-open grazing law.

• May 20, 2021
Governor Ortom and President Buhari
Governor Samuel Ortom and President Muhammadu Buhari

The Abuja Division of the Federal High Court has rejected a suit seeking to compel President Muhammadu Buhari to direct security agencies to enforce the Benue Open Grazing Prohibition and Ranching Law of 2017.

Delivering judgment in a virtual court proceeding, Justice Ijeoma Ojukwu held that the court lacked the jurisdiction to entertain the suit and consequentially struck it out.

The suit was instituted by Mathew Nyiutsa against the president on the grounds that the president, by his oath of office, incurred a mandatory obligation to uphold and preserve the law of the land.

He, however, said that the president failed to abide by his oath of office when he refused to implement the Benue Open Grazing Prohibition and Ranching Law.

The plaintiff maintained that despite the existence of the law, herders have remained unrelenting in practising open grazing, engaging in killings and destruction of property in Benue.

Fulani-Herdsmen
Photo of a Fulani herder used to depict the story ( Photo Credit: Vanguard Newspaper)

He added that the president had failed or refused to enforce the law, in view of his oath of office, by using the security and enforcement apparatus within his powers.

The judge held that the failure of the president to discharge his official responsibilities in accordance with his oath of office was not justiciable and that the court could not hold the president accountable for not abiding by his oath of office.

“In my view, the courts do not have the jurisdiction to entertain any suit bordering on compliance with the oath of office of the president for the reason that it is not justiciable.

The judge said that though the anti-open grazing law was validly enacted, it was the responsibility of the people of Benue and law enforcement agencies and the task force to employ all legitimate means to implement the anti-open grazing law.

“There is no contest that the Open Grazing Prohibition and Ranching establishment law 2017 was validly passed by the Benue House of Assembly and that the law is still in force, especially as the law has not been struck down by any court of law or court of competent jurisdiction.

“The implementation, therefore, lies with the machinery of the state and law enforcement agencies like the police, whose duty is to maintain law and order and to secure lives and properties in accordance with Section Four of the Police Act,” she said.

According to her, it is not the duty of the defendant. It is only where there is an infraction of the provisions of that law that the court may be invited to impose the prescribed sanctions.

“In so far as the president has not issued an executive order, which runs contrary to the said law, this court cannot hold him accountable,” the judge said.

Justice Ojukwu equally held that by the provisions of Section 308 of the 1999 Constitution, the plaintiff was wrong to have sued the president in his personal capacity on an issue related to the performance of his official responsibilities.

“The immunity provided in Section 308 of the Constitution is to protect the occupier of the offices named in the section against the institution of either civil or criminal suit against him/her and from being sued in a personal capacity while in office,” she held.

She held that the plaintiff went outside the official capacity by adding the personal name of the person currently occupying the office to the suit as a defendant.

“The proper defendant, in this case, ought to have been the President, Federal Republic of Nigeria.

“The life of this suit cannot be sustained if, for any reason, President Muhammadu Buhari ceases to be in office.

“This cannot be the position of the law since governance is a continuum and does not terminate because the tenure of office of a particular officeholder has elapsed,” she said.

She added that the proper defendant in the alternative, should have been the Attorney-General of the Federation and the defendant on record (Buhari) would have been a nominal party.

Counsel to the plaintiff, Terhemba Agbe thanked the judge for the judgment saying it was very educating.

(NAN)

We have recently deactivated our website's comment provider in favour of other channels of distribution and commentary. We encourage you to join the conversation on our stories via our Facebook, Twitter and other social media pages.

More from Peoples Gazette

Nigerian Bar Association

States

Independence: NBA urges Nigerians to expect better future

The NBA said that ordinary Nigerians should be deriving benefit from the subsidy removal rather than hardship.

farmers

Agriculture

FG tasks ECOWAS on leveraging financing strategies for agroecology

The federal government has urged stakeholders in the agriculture and finance sectors in the West Africa region to leverage financing strategies to enhance agroecology practices

Katsina State

Politics

Katsina youths pledge to deliver over 2 million votes to Atiku

“Katsina State is Atiku’s political base because it is his second home.”

Guinea-Bissau vs Madagascar

Sport

2027 AFCON Qualifier: Guinea-Bissau beat Madagascar, extend lead over Nigeria in Group L

Guinea-Bissau now have 10 points, Nigeria seven points, while Madagascar and Tanzania have two points each.

Ebola patients

Africa

WHO raises concern over rising Bundibugyo Ebola deaths, insecurity in DR Congo

Mr Ghebreyesus said the outbreak, declared six months ago, had spread across 67 health zones in eight provinces in the DR Congo.

Afreximbank

Africa

Afreximbank urges industries to boost intra-African trade as alternative to China in global markets

“As global markets look to diversify production beyond China, Africa must position itself as a natural partner of choice,” Mr Maayergi said.

Russell Brand

World

Russell Brand faces probe over prison message to supporters

Mr Brand was convicted at Southwark Crown Court of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault.

President Bola Tinubu and hungry Nigerians

Politics

Tinubu admits cost-of-living crisis after APC dismissed widespread hunger claims

According to Mr Tinubu, the 2027 election is about the country’s future and direction.

CERVICAL SCREENING EQUIPMENT

World

WHO pushes for stronger vaccination, screening, treatment to eliminate cervical cancer

WHO said that expanding HPV vaccination, improving screening access, and ensuring timely treatment are critical to protecting women.