He said the four other pastors were responding to treatment at the hospital.
The police commissioner added that the four suspects would be arraigned after the completion of investigation.
Mr Alabo said Mr Julius replaced Bartholomew Onyeka, who had been redeployed to Benue Command.
The officer has served in various states nationwide in operational, administrative and investigative capacities.
Mr Onyeka said that upon handing over the suspect, the police commenced investigations, and four locally-fabricated rifles were recovered from his house.
He urged them to stop the destruction of lives and properties by deploying its personnel to prevent further attacks.
Police have sealed the secretariats of all 17 local government councils in Plateau.
According to Mr Alabo, the students were abducted on Monday night at their hostel located outside the campus.
In the process, they started shooting the illegal operators and a stray bullet hit Ofezie, who was sitting in his shop at the market.
The police command in Plateau has arrested an inspector, Solomon Damak, for shooting a man, Nyommena Salah, over an election argument.
