The curious case of Justice Peter Lifu and his coconut head

What happens when a coconut head wears a judge’s wig?
I have been worried about the quality of judges we have in Nigeria for a while now. Being that I know nothing about law other than what I see on TV, I have learnt to zip my mouth about the quality of reasoning behind some of the judgments our judges have delivered in modern times. It doesn’t mean I am not troubled by them. I default to that position of the unlearned who take it that the judges must know what they are doing.
There has to be a world where it makes sense that someone who did not campaign for an elective post is declared the winner because he lost his party’s primary in a manner the judge considers unfair. Definitely, there must be a universe where a fellow who came fourth in an election is declared the winner of the election because of something the judge tagged as unfair on the part of the winner.
As a coconut head in good standing, I concede that understanding such advanced, delicate, multilevel reasoning is beyond my pay grade. My JAMB score is there as proof of my deficiencies.
At one point, I assumed that once judges put those wigs on their bald heads, some aquatic cells become dislocated in their brains. It was the only way an ordinary man like me could make sense of the shenanigans we are often forced to take from the Nigerian bench.
Some old lawyers I have consulted put it in football terms. They said that Nigeria’s current judicial bench is not deep. They always go back to the days of Oputa, Elias, and others as examples of a time when the Nigerian judicial bench was deep, independent, and blessed with a good dose of men and women of honour.
They said that at that time, judges like Oputa would not let characters like the Federal Capital Territory Minister, Nyesom Wike, into their space, let alone their homes. And if he drove in without an invitation, Oputa would walk him out of his house. Of course, such a thing cannot happen now when the house is one that Wike built and donated to the judge.
Who born the judge that can do such a thing? It is the fastest way to become homeless in Abuja. And who knows how many of these judges have children schooling abroad, doctors abroad, and how many of the likes of Wike are facilitating such expensive ventures?
The day even I, an unlearned fellow, understood that something was wrong with our judiciary was when Judge Omotosho delivered judgment in Nnamdi Kanu’s case. I was not mad because he mentioned my name in a case I had nothing to do with. My shock was at how poorly he represented the Nigerian judiciary that day. Watching him, unable to read a judgment I assumed he had helped to write, made me wonder if The Gambia or Zambia would continue to demand the services of Nigerian judges after that abysmal performance.
Anyway, let me get back to the coconut-head judge. So, the man Kalu Kalu called a coconut judge is Mr Peter Lifu. He is a Federal High Court judge in Abuja. He handled two cases concerning the Nigerian opposition party, the ADC.
Let us start with the second case. It was a case that asked Peter Lifu to nullify the ADC’s candidates in the upcoming election.
At the time the Chief Judge of the Federal High Court, Mr John Tsoho, assigned this second case to Peter Lifu, Lifu was already presiding over a case seeking his court’s deregistration of the ADC.
Even with my coconut head, I knew there was no sensible way to ask a man who was already looking at the first case of deregistering a political party to be the same person to decide on another case demanding the nullification of the candidates of the same political party in the upcoming election.
A coconut head like me knows that it is inappropriate. But not Peter Lifu and not Mr John Tsoho.
Six days after Lifu received the case from Tsoho, Nigeria’s Court of Appeal ordered Lifu to stay the proceedings.
Of course, as expected, that little nza bird called Peter Lifu, mesmerised by the drum that the likes of Nyesom Wike were beating for him in the bushes, ignored the Court of Appeal and went ahead to deliver his verdict to deregister the ADC.
The people beating the drum for Peter Lifu, the coconut head judge, clapped for him.
He liked the applause so much that he moved ahead with the second case. His oga, coconut head John Tsoho, did not see anything wrong with letting Lifu continue with the second case. After all, there were other honourable judges under Tsoho to whom he could have given the case.
Not even when the Nigerian Court of Appeal overturned Peter Lifu’s judgment on the deregistration of the ADC did coconut head Peter Lifu say to himself, “Shame dey catch me.” No.
In overturning his judgment in the deregistration case, the Court of Appeal chastised Lifu. In layman’s language, the Court of Appeal called Lifu a coconut head.
Despite all that, Lifu’s oga at the top, Tsoho, did not feel any shame either. He allowed Lifu to continue with the second case.
This is when you would expect the NBA to yell at the bench and tell them that they are embarrassing all legal practitioners in Nigeria. More importantly, warn the bench that if they are not careful, they may make the likes of Dr Damages register at Abuja University for an evening law degree.
By the way, the ADC asked Lifu to recuse himself from the second case for obvious reasons, but he refused. And his band members kept jamming from their positions in the forest.
Our nza bird, Peter Lifu, kept dancing.
He finally delivered his judgment on 5 November. And as soon as he was done, he finally slept.
The kid, nza bird, and coconut head had eaten what had kept him up at night. He slept until the next time his “client” brought him another case to execute.
My only issue in this whole matter is with Kalu Kalu, the lawyer who went on TV and called our nza bird dancing on the dusty road a coconut judge. Did he mean to say “coconut head judge,” or is it “coconut judge”? As for his withdrawal of that statement, he can now see that it did not stop the Nigerian Bar Association from referring him to a disciplinary committee for possible punishment.
I have zero sympathy for you, Kalu Kalu. To you, I say, ntoooooooo. Next time, you should know the difference between calling Peter Lifu a coconut judge and calling him by his appropriate title, coconut head judge.
- Rudolf Ogoo Okonkwo teaches Post-colonial African History, Diasporic African Literature, and African Folktales at the School of Visual Arts in New York City. He is the author of “This American Life Sef.” His latest book is “A Kiss That Never Was.”
We have recently deactivated our website's comment provider in favour of other channels of distribution and commentary. We encourage you to join the conversation on our stories via our Facebook, Twitter and other social media pages.
More from Peoples Gazette

States
Independence: NBA urges Nigerians to expect better future
The NBA said that ordinary Nigerians should be deriving benefit from the subsidy removal rather than hardship.

Agriculture
FG tasks ECOWAS on leveraging financing strategies for agroecology
The federal government has urged stakeholders in the agriculture and finance sectors in the West Africa region to leverage financing strategies to enhance agroecology practices

Politics
Katsina youths pledge to deliver over 2 million votes to Atiku
“Katsina State is Atiku’s political base because it is his second home.”

Politics
Shettima hails Buhari’s modesty, commitment to national service
Mr Shettima described former President Muhammadu Buhari as a leader whose modest lifestyle, self-restraint and patriotism distinguished him.

Opinion
The curious case of Justice Peter Lifu and his coconut head
Not even when the Nigerian Court of Appeal overturned Peter Lifu’s judgment on the deregistration of the ADC did coconut head Peter Lifu say to himself, “Shame dey catch me.”

States
NSCDC intercepts 32-year-old man over illegal firearms possession in Ebonyi
The Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps says it has arrested a 32-year-old man, Nwite Idoko, for illegal possession of firearms.

Politics
Gov Otti presents N1.2 trillion 2027 Appropriation Bill to Abia assembly
Governor Alex Otti of Abia, on Thursday, presented N1.2 trillion 2027 Appropriation Bill to the House of Assembly for consideration and approval.

States
INEC tells young female Nigerians to vote in 2027 elections
INEC’s resident electoral commissioner in Rivers, Johnson Sinikiem, made the call at a zonal awareness creation workshop for young female voters in Port Harcourt on Thursday.

Economy
Removal of fuel subsidy boosted development in Nasarawa: Gov Sule
Governor Abdullahi Sule says the removal of fuel subsidy by President Bola Tinubu in 2023 has provided states with additional resources to accelerate development.





