Uber loses five-year legal battle over driver employment status

Uber lost a five-year-long legal fight in the U.K. on Friday, as the Supreme Court ruled that its drivers should be classified as workers instead of independent contractors.
“Working time is not limited to periods when driving passengers,” Judge George Leggatt said in a summary of the ruling. It also “includes any period when a driver is logged into the app and ready and willing to accept trips.”
The ruling concluded the legal tussle between Uber and a group of former drivers who claimed they were workers entitled to employment rights like a minimum wage, holiday pay, and rest breaks.
The Supreme Court came to this decision, saying the relationship between the ride-hailing company and its drivers is that of “subordination and dependency” as Uber sets the prices for each ride the drivers carry out, and the drivers are not permitted to set their own prices as they would if they were self-employed and sets the terms and conditions of using its service, and actively prevents drivers from reaching agreements with riders outside the app.
The suit was initiated by two drivers in 2016, who argued that they should be considered “workers” rather than self-employed.
It was established in the employment tribunal that the drivers were “workers” and that they were working whenever the Uber app was switched on or within the territory authorised to work; and were able and willing to accept assignments.
These findings were subsequently upheld by the employment appeal tribunal and the appeal court.
Uber has been embroiled in several legal actions over the state of its drivers.
In March 2020, judges in France ruled that Uber drivers were employees. In the United States, initial rulings given in California in favour of worker status for Uber and Lyft drivers were overturned in a state-wide referendum.
In Germany, the company was required to work with licensed private vehicle companies after being banned in 2015.
We have recently deactivated our website's comment provider in favour of other channels of distribution and commentary. We encourage you to join the conversation on our stories via our Facebook, Twitter and other social media pages.
More from Peoples Gazette

Agriculture
FG tasks ECOWAS on leveraging financing strategies for agroecology
The federal government has urged stakeholders in the agriculture and finance sectors in the West Africa region to leverage financing strategies to enhance agroecology practices

Politics
Katsina youths pledge to deliver over 2 million votes to Atiku
“Katsina State is Atiku’s political base because it is his second home.”

States
Oyo police arrest man, recover pistol, drugs
The police said the investigation is ongoing, with efforts intensified to identify, track, and apprehend the fleeing suspects.

States
Gov. Sani appoints new aides, board chairs to enhance service delivery
Mr Musa said that the appointments are part of the ongoing efforts to strengthen governance and inject fresh energy into public service.

States
Police detain suspect over illegal possession of firearm in Enugu
The police said a concealed locally made double-barrelled pistol was found in the suspect’s possession during a search.

Politics
Appeal Court upholds judgment barring INEC from recognising Mark-led ADC congresses
Justice Mohammed held that the case that precipitated the restraining order bordered on a non-justiciable internal affair of a political party.

Heading 5
NMDPRA seals Mobil, Mangerborn Energy in Ogun for under-dispensing fuel
Mr Adebowale stated that the action became necessary due to repeated breaches of regulatory requirements by the affected filling stations.

Politics
Court adjourns Sokoto ADC leadership suit until July 22
The judge consequently adjourned the matter to July 22 and ordered counsel for the first defendant to pay a fine of ₦500,000 to the court.





