Friday, April 19, 2024

Blasphemy: Lawyer walks out on judge over denial of application 

At the resumed sitting, Mr Shehu-Usman, prayed the court to allow the defendant move a no-case submission.

• July 7, 2022
Sheikh Abduljabbar Kabara
Sheikh Abduljabbar Kabara [Photo credit: BBC]

A mild drama ensued at the ongoing trial of Kano cleric Sheikh Abduljabbar Kabara, on Thursday as defence counsel, Dalhatu Shehu-Usman walked out on the judge.

The Kano State Government charged Mr Kabara with four counts bordering on blasphemous comments against Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) on Aug.10, Oct. 25 and Dec. 20, 2019.

The defence counsel had on June 23, prayed the court to discharge his client on grounds that the entire charge slammed against him was not based on law.

At the resumed  sitting, Mr Shehu-Usman, prayed the court to allow the defendant move a no-case submission.

“The court did not establish prima facie before allowing the defendant to start calling his witness relying on section 357and 303 of ACJL, 2019.

“The position of law is for the court to give bench ruling without any adjournment as well as criminal trial is mandatory to  accord the defendant an opportunity to defend himself,” he argued.

The defence counsel opposed the cross-examination made by the prosecution and threatened to walk out of the court.

“Why will the prosecution be asking the defendant when did his father die? It is not contained in the charge,” he said.

He also requested for a copy of the proceedings, adding that he will challenge the ruling before an Upper court.

Earlier, the judge permitted the prosecution to go ahead with cross examination and the defence counsel picked up his belongings and walked out on the judge.

The prosecution counsel, Yakubu Abdullahi, opposed the prayer to give room for no case submission, arguing that the cleric had already commenced his defence.

Mr Abdullahi argued that the former defence counsel, Ambali Muhammmad, SAN, told the court that he was not interested in applying for a no-case submission on behalf of the defendant.

During cross-examination Mr Abdullahi asked the defendant when his father died and how old he was then.

“After your father’s death, where did you continue your education?” He asked.

The defendant told the court that his father Sheikh Dr Nasir Kabara died in 1996.

“I was 25 or 26-years-old then and after his death I did not attend any school in Nigeria.”

The presiding judge, Ibrahim Sarki-Yola, said that the defence counsel had the power to challenge the content of the charge slammed against his client at any stage of the trial.

He, however, affirmed that the defence counsel lacks legal power to apply for a no case submission when the defendant has already begun his defence.

He adjourned the matter until July 21, for continuation of defence.

The state alleged that the defendant made a blasphemous comment against Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) in his marriage with Nana Safiyya in Jautul Fara, Section 93 (40) and hadith 1,365 and 1,428. Sahih-Bukhari and Muslim.

(NAN)

We have recently deactivated our website's comment provider in favour of other channels of distribution and commentary. We encourage you to join the conversation on our stories via our Facebook, Twitter and other social media pages.

More from Peoples Gazette

Katsina State

Politics

Katsina youths pledge to deliver over 2 million votes to Atiku

“Katsina State is Atiku’s political base because it is his second home.”

NIGERIANS WORKING IN CHINESE FACTORY

Rights

About one million people in forced labour in Nigeria, National Bureau of Statistics reveals

“While 36.9 per cent of individuals in forced labour in their current job are found in the service sector, other than domestic work,” said the report.

NIGERIAN-MADE VEHICLES

Economy

FG asks stakeholders to manufacture, export Nigerian-made vehicles

The minister said the government was doing all necessary to ensure this was achieved, thus requiring stakeholders also to play their role.

ESN OPERATIVES AND NIGERIAN SOLDIERS

States

One soldier killed, two wounded in gunfight with IPOB/ESN militants in Okija: Army

“The bravery and dedication of our troops in the face of danger are testimonies of their unwavering commitment to protecting the people and communities,” said the army.

BIDEN; HAMAS

World

U.S. vetoes Palestine’s request for full UN membership

The Security Council on Thursday rejected Palestine’s request for UN membership, with the United States casting a veto.

António Guterres

World

Hamas-Israel War: UN appeals for restraint in Middle East

“Ending the hostilities in Gaza would significantly defuse tensions across the region,” Mr Guterres said.

Student at Culture Art Academy event

Lagos

Nigerian students warned against foreign cultures

“However, in educating students, they have been exposed to norms and values from foreign cultures…and the children then exhibit strange behaviours,” said Mr Buraimoh.