Sunday, May 26, 2024

Suspended UNICAL dean asks court to quash sexual harassment charge against him

“The name Joe Odey Agi, SAN, is not on the roll of Legal Practitioners in Nigeria.”

• April 16, 2024
CYRIL NDIFON
CYRIL NDIFON [Credit: Law and society Magazine]

The suspended Dean of Faculty of Law, University of Calabar Cross River State, Prof. Cyril Ndifon, has prayed a Federal High Court, Abuja, to quash the sexual harassment charge against him.

Mr Ndifon, who told Justice James Omotosho in a further affidavit filed by his lawyer, Joe Agi, SAN, insisted that the Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission’s counsel, Osuobeni Akponimisingha, handling the case, was not qualified to practise as lawyer.

He restated that Mr Akponimisingha’s name is allegedly not on the roll of Legal Practitioners in Nigeria pursuant to Section 2 of the Legal Practitioners Act.

Further affidavit, deposed to by Mr Ndifon’s co-defendant, Sunny Anyanwu, was in response to ICPC lawyer’s counter affidavit filed against their motion on notice.

The suspended dean, in the earlier motion dated and filed March 15, had told the court that the amended charge was incompetent as a result of the disputed identity of the anti-graft agency’s lawyer.

He said the development had robbed the court of its jurisdiction to entertain the matter.

He, therefore, prayed the court to quash the four-count charge against him and his co-defendant, Mr Anyanwu.

Mr Akponimisingha, in his counter affidavit dated March 20, accused the suspended dean and his legal team of being jealous of his academic qualifications.

The lawyer, who attached his Nigerian Bar Association’s Practising Licence document dated 2016 with the counter affidavit, said he graduated from law school.

He said contrary to the defence argument, the appellation “Dr” added to his name was as a result of an additional academic qualification acquired by him after he had been called to the bar as a legal practitioner.

He also alleged that the names of the lead counsel to the defendants, Joe Agi, SAN and other senior advocates appearing with him in the criminal case, were not on roll of Legal Practitioners in Nigeria with the appendage of “SAN.”

He argued that the fact that the appellation “Dr” was added to his name did not make the amended charge liable to be struck out.

Mr Akponimisingha said he was duly called to the Nigerian Bar and had been licensed to practise law in the country.

“That I know as a fact that justices presiding over cases in courts in Nigeria were called to the Bar only with their given names without the appellation ‘Hon. Justice.’ Therefore, the appellation ‘Hon. Justice’ added to their names by reason of their appointment as judges does not render their judgments invalid because their names do not appear on the roll call of Legal Practitioners as ‘Hon. Justices.’

“The name Joe Odey Agi, SAN, is not on the roll of Legal Practitioners in Nigeria. What exists on the roll is Agi Joseph Odey, year of call, 1985,” he said

Mr Akponimisingha told the court that the present application by the defence was a delay tactic deployed to stall the smooth trial of the charge. He urged the court to discountenance their plea.

But Mr Ndifon, in a further affidavit deposed to by Mr Anyanwu, a co-defendant, stated that contrary to Mr Akponimisingha’s argument, the defence was not challenging the appellation “Dr” added to his name.

Rather, he said their contention was that the name “Osuobeni Ekoi Akponimisingha is not on the roll of Legal Practitioners in Nigeria and that a search conducted on the roll of Legal Practitioners in Nigeria revealed that one Ekoi A. Osuobeni was called to the Bar in Nigeria in 2012.

He stated, “A copy of the computer print-out of the name of the said Ekoi A. Osuobeni from the Nigerian Bar Association portal showing the names of’ legal practitioners on the roll in Nigeria as well as
the certificate of compliance is attached as Exhibits B and C.”

The suspended dean contended that there was a word of difference between “Osuobeni Ekoi Akponimisingha” and “Ekoi A. Osuobeni.”

According to him, both names are not the same person for the purpose of a professional register sanctioned by law pursuant to the Legal Practitioners Act.

He urged the court to strike out the suit in the interest of justice.

When the matter was called on Monday, the ICPC lawyer told Justice Omotosho that the defendant brought a letter stating that the learned silk in the matter was having another matter at the Supreme Court.

Fisong Fidelis, who appeared for the defence, confirmed filing the letter before the court.

Justice Omotosho, who expressed his displeasure about the way the matter had degenerated, said parties had left the main issue “and are now attacking their academic qualifications.”

“I owe a duty to this court to protect the integrity of the legal profession. I don’t like the way this matter is going,” the judge held.

The judge, therefore, directed the lawyers of the parties, including representatives of Federation of International Women Lawyers and NBA, to meet with him in his chambers on Wednesday so they could take a position on the development.

Justice Omotosho consequently fixed April 19 to rule on Mr Ndifon’s motion seeking an order allowing the defendants to have an independent forensic examiner to look at some of the exhibits tendered by the ICPC.

Mr Ndifon was, on January 25, re-arraigned alongside Mr Anyanwu on an amended four-count charge bordering on alleged sexual harassment and an attempt to perverse the cause of justice.

Mr Anyanwu, who is one of the lawyers in the defence, was joined in the amended charge filed on January 22 by the ICPC on allegation that he called TKJ, the star witness, on her mobile telephone during the pendency of the charge against Mr Ndifon to threaten her.

(NAN)

We have recently deactivated our website's comment provider in favour of other channels of distribution and commentary. We encourage you to join the conversation on our stories via our Facebook, Twitter and other social media pages.

More from Peoples Gazette

Katsina State

Politics

Katsina youths pledge to deliver over 2 million votes to Atiku

“Katsina State is Atiku’s political base because it is his second home.”

Sean Baker at Cannes festival

Showbiz

Sean Baker’s “Anora” clinches Palme d’Or at Cannes festival

He is the first American director to win the Palme since Terrence Malick’s 2012 victory with “The Tree of Life.” 

Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC)

NationWide

Tinubu’s credit scheme to protect Nigerians from unregistered loan firms: FCCPC

Mr Abdullahi said the scheme will reduce the rate at which Nigerians patronise unregistered loan applications.

Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC)

NationWide

Electricity issues topped customers’ complaints to FCCPC last year

Mr Adullahi said that the MacArthur foundation granted funds to intervene in the electricity sector.

NationWide

Ex-EFCC chairman, Lamorde, dies, corpse to arrive Nigeria from Egypt Monday

He passed away in an Egyptian hospital while undergoing kidney stone surgery.

Dollars

Economy

CBN bans bureau de change operators from street trading of forex

“Street trading of foreign currencies is not allowed.’’

Nicki Minaj

Showbiz

Nicki Minaj detained at Amsterdam airport over alleged drug possession, released after fine payment

“This is what it looks like when people are paid big money to try to sabotage a tour after all else failed.’’